Susan Seidelman’s Smithereens (1982) and Alex Ross Perry’s Her Scent (2019), which play back-to-back on the Brattle Theatre subsequent week (Aug. 15) as a punk rock double function, are movies made in fully totally different keys. One, Smithereens, is a snapshot of a 1980s New York Metropolis that not exists, captured in its gritty, pure realism by a feminine director who solely now appears to be getting the form of respect and retrospective research that her male friends obtained earlier than her. The opposite, Her Scent, is virtually within the construction of a play, 5 acts of acrobatic, dramatic appearing that retains up the artifice of a interval piece (principally set within the early 90s) and abrasive psychological drama with intentionally cacophonous soundscapes. Each are about sophisticated, flawed feminine characters. Not a lot “troublesome ladies” however ladies surviving, eschewing their anticipated roles from society, transgressing respectability and residing on the sting, hazard feeling like it could possibly come at a second’s discover all whereas the music continues to play.
Smithereens was Seidelman’s feature-length debut and could be the primary American impartial movie (it was shot on 16mm with solely a $40,000 funds and no location permits) ever chosen to be in competitors on the Cannes Movie Competition. It follows Jersey woman Wren (Susan Berman, a theater actress in her function movie debut), who has left the Backyard State with aspirations to be in with the New York punk rock scene. She barely scrapes by, counting on petty thefts and muggings dedicated on the subway, residing as a drive of nature who’s routinely put down and humbled by these round her—however not with out a struggle.
After being kicked out of her condominium, she crashes in vans and residences of punks, together with sharing a mattress with a musician (Richard Hell) in a one-hit marvel band referred to as Smithereens. It turns into clear that she is misplaced. She needs to have greater issues occurring, however can’t appear to get there. She needs to be a punk determine, however doesn’t preserve a powerful curiosity in being a musician. As an alternative Wren simply passes round fliers for the Smithereens and will get the CBGBs New York punk look down pat (houndstooth skirts, clashing colours and patterns, fishnet stockings and crimson high-top sneakers). She has ambition, however what can manifest from that past surviving one other tough New York evening? She is surrounded by the decrepit, rubbled areas of a metropolis on its knees, and it appears troublesome to fathom what she will do to face out and construct herself up into anyone. The music soundtrack within the movie is carried by the guitar strings, utilizing all the things from Richard Hell and the Voidoids to the Feelies, making a jagged momentum that has Wren in fixed, chaotic movement. When is she not hustling? There’s an simple punk spirit in Smithereens, but in addition a self-awareness in regards to the futility of its abrasive lead character. Berman’s Wren isn’t devoid of excellent qualities—however she is just too cussed to confess how in over her personal head she is, as her instincts come again to chew her time and time once more. As she asks one other character within the aftermath of one other brawl she was in—“Inform me the reality: am I, like, actually terrible or one thing?”
The New York that Seidelman presents in Smithereens is an city jungle, with a number of the wilderness excavated, however this house additionally served as a fertile floor that might develop into extra potentialities. That maybe spoke extra to Seidelman than Wren. Seidelman might be most synonymous together with her persona swap movie Desperately Searching for Susan (1985) with Rosanna Arquette and Madonna (undoubtedly the most effective movie she has ever been in), additionally characterised by a punk spirit but in addition imbued with extra of a pop filmmaking accessibility and sensibility. She made different movies to much less success and significant acclaim within the years that adopted, however continued working a technique or one other for many years. Her work on tv, most notably directing the Intercourse and the Metropolis pilot, felt like a continuation of her working commentary on the altering face of New York Metropolis (seen there absolutely Giuliani-fied)—simply because it continued her efforts to proceed depicting prickly, sophisticated feminine characters, on this case by going from large display screen to small display screen.
With Her Scent, Alex Ross Perry and Elisabeth Moss current their third movie collectively as writer-director and actress. They began with Pay attention Up Philip (2014) throughout Moss’s run as Peggy Olson on Mad Males. In that, Moss was a breath of recent air foil and exasperated girlfriend to Jason Schwartzman’s immodest, acidic creator Philip Friedman (a complete part of the movie is devoted to her character Ashley gaining her braveness, and leaving her boyfriend). They adopted that up with a 180-degree character flip in Queen of Earth (2015) the place Moss’s psychological breakdown because the grieving Catherine Hewitt is as in-your-face (in close-ups and in any other case) as a movie can get with its lead character. However Becky One thing as performed by Moss nonetheless manages to shock. It’s a powerhouse, a full-bodied efficiency like she has by no means completed earlier than. Indebted to Perry’s personal proclivities as a filmmaker, Elisabeth Moss as Becky One thing is Courtney Love meets a John Cassavetes heroine with a six-string.
Because the troubled lead singer of the band One thing She (with songs written Bully’s Alicia Bognanno, a baby of riot grrrl), Moss embodies a born performer—filled with bombastic declarations, it appears she is at all times on. Her Scent spends a exceptional period of time backstage as Becky’s bandmates attempt to placed on one other present. However Becky has different concepts. There are occasions the place she is off-screen, constructing a pressure together with her risky unpredictability and Moss’s efficiency is simply so evocative that—whereas by no means seeing Becky taking medicine—the viewers can visualize her getting excessive and making hassle wherever she could also be. Becky’s bandmates, Marielle (Agyness Deyn) and Ali (Gayle Rankin) are at their wit’s finish making an attempt to stability their very own demons whereas babysitting their good friend. Her mom Ania (Virginia Madsen) is a dumbfounded witness to what her daughter has turn out to be. Her ex-husband (Dan Stevens) is searching for to maintain their younger daughter away from her till she will get sober. Her Scent, whereas displaying temporary snippets of Becky’s life earlier than the downslide, drops its viewers instantly amid the autumn, within the throes and practically hostage to Becky’s efficiency and fractured way of thinking.
Longtime Perry collaborator and cinematographer Sean Worth Williams completely calibrates the rhythms of digital camera motion that put the viewers within the motions of Becky. It’s immersive however conscious that no one can’t cease the momentum of this crash. Then, a change occurs. Becky positive factors the attention and data that she put so many others by an emotional and psychological buzzsaw. It requires her to reside with the choices she made when beneath the affect, selections which have eternally knowledgeable how she is seen by so many individuals, as each particular person and public determine, an avatar of a sound, a scene, and an perspective. Her Scent is finally certainly one of 2019’s greatest movies, a profession excessive level for each Perry and Moss, who faucet right into a messier, extra alienating character research than they ever have earlier than at centerstage.
Smithereens and Her Scent present sophisticated ladies on the middle of very totally different punk worlds and durations which can be fully of a chunk within the sensibilities of each of their administrators. You see the hustle to be well-known and in addition see fame being misplaced second by second. These are imperfect characters making errors, unable, it appears, to assist themselves. What’s their all-time low, and if both Wren or Becky hit all-time low, will they get well? These are two ladies among the many ruins of punk rock who desire a second act. Will they get it?
SMITHEREENS AND HER SMELL PLAY AT THE BRATTLE THEATRE AS A DOUBLE FEATURE ON THU eight.15. HER SMELL PLAYS AT 2:15 AND 7PM, SMITHEREENS AT 5 AND 9:45PM. BOTH FILMS AVAILABLE ON BLU-RAY, DVD, AND VOD OUTLETS.
CADEN MARK GARDNER
Caden Mark Gardner is a contract movie critic from Upstate New York
Newest posts by CADEN MARK GARDNER (see all)